Last updated: September 2026 · Written by Alex Trent, MA, MS, mental health billing specialist
Quick answer: Medical insurance claims are usually denied for one of three types of mistakes: administrative (inactive coverage, missing information, no prior authorization), coding (codes that don’t match, bundled services billed separately, the wrong level of service), or documentation (records that don’t prove medical necessity). Most of these can be prevented. Verify eligibility and benefits before the first visit, get authorizations in writing, code from complete session notes, and scrub every claim before you submit it. If a claim is still denied, you can appeal it with supporting documentation.
A claim denial happens when an insurance company processes a claim and refuses to pay all or part of it. Do not assume every returned claim is an adjudicated denial. Check the acknowledgment or remittance notice before deciding how to respond. In Medicare Part B, CGS explains that claims returned as unprocessable for incomplete or invalid information have no appeal rights and must be corrected and resubmitted as new claims. That is different from an adjudicated denial. For an adjudicated claim, follow the payer’s applicable correction, reopening or appeal instructions; CMS says minor-error corrections do not go through the Medicare appeals process.
Almost every denial falls into one of three categories:
Each reason below matches a Claim Adjustment Reason Code (CARC) you’ll see on the EOB or ERA. For every code you get what it means, a real-world mental health example, and the fix: how to prevent it and what to do if the denial has already happened. Jump to a code:
CO-16 · OA-18 · CO-22 · CO-27 · CO-29 · CO-50 · CO-97 · CO-109 · CO-151 · CO-197
What the code means: “Claim/service lacks information or has submission/billing error(s).” Experian Health’s 2025 survey ranked missing or inaccurate claim data first among reported denial triggers. X12 requires at least one accompanying remark code, either an NCPDP Reject Reason Code or a Remittance Advice Remark Code that is not an ALERT. X12 also says not to use CARC 16 for claims attachments or other documentation. Read the accompanying code and payer instructions to identify the issue rather than assuming CARC 16 identifies a specific incorrect field.
Mental health example: A therapist bills 90837 for a video session but leaves off the rendering provider NPI and uses place of service 11 (office) instead of 10 (telehealth in the patient’s home). The payer denies with CO-16 and remark code N290 (missing rendering provider).
The fix: Scan the insurance card at intake and enter the name exactly as it appears. Run every claim through a scrubber that checks NPIs, taxonomy, place of service and modifiers. Read the remittance and accompanying remark code, then check the payer’s correction instructions and the claim’s status. Do not choose an appeal or frequency code 7 from CO-16 alone. CGS Medicare Part B instructs providers to correct claims returned as unprocessable and resubmit them as new claims; those claims have no appeal rights. For an adjudicated claim, UnitedHealthcare’s corrected-claim guidance calls for frequency code 7 and the original claim number. CMS separately directs minor-error corrections outside the Medicare appeals process.
What the code means: “Exact duplicate claim/service.” X12 specifies group code OA for CARC 18, except where state workers’ compensation regulations require CO. Read the actual remittance rather than assuming every duplicate adjustment is CO-18.
Mental health example: A practice hasn’t been paid for a 90834 session after 30 days, so the biller submits the same claim again as a new claim. The original was still in process. The second claim comes back with CARC 18, generally paired with group code OA. The same thing happens when a practice fixes an error and sends a brand-new claim instead of a corrected one.
The fix: Check claim status in the payer portal or with a 276/277 inquiry before resubmitting. UnitedHealthcare advises waiting for the original claim to be adjudicated before a correction and using frequency code 7 with the original claim number for its corrected-claim process. Follow the applicable payer’s instructions rather than using that format for every returned claim. If a claim is identified as a duplicate, reconcile the original claim’s status and payment before deciding whether any further action is needed.
What the code means: “This care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits.” The payer thinks another plan should be billed first, or the client hasn’t updated their COB information.
Mental health example: A 14-year-old client is covered by both parents’ employer plans. If the plans’ coordination rules make the father’s coverage primary, billing the mother’s plan first may result in a coordination-of-benefits adjustment. The birthday rule compares parents’ birth month and day, not age; Aetna’s guidance applies it to a child covered by both parents’ plans when the parents live together, with separate rules for other family arrangements and court orders. Do not select the primary plan from birthdays alone without checking the applicable rules. Medicare coordination follows separate Medicare Secondary Payer rules, not this dependent-child birthday rule.
The fix: Collect all active coverage and confirm the primary/secondary order under the applicable plans’ coordination rules. For dependent children, check whether the birthday rule or another family/court-order rule applies; for Medicare beneficiaries, use the applicable Medicare Secondary Payer rules. Review the actual remittance: X12 defines CARC 22 as care that may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits. If coordination information is outdated, follow the insurer’s update instructions, including any action it requires from the member. Follow the confirmed payer order and the secondary payer’s requirements for reporting the primary payer’s adjudication.
What the code means: “Expenses incurred after coverage terminated.” The policy ended, lapsed for non-payment, or changed before the date of service.
Mental health example: A client in weekly therapy loses their job in March and doesn’t elect COBRA. The practice keeps billing the old plan for April and May sessions, and eight claims come back CO-27 weeks later.
The fix: Check eligibility and benefits for the planned service date before providing care, following the applicable plan’s verification guidance. Do not rely only on intake, monthly or January checks; confirm current coverage when a client reports a change and at subsequent visits as the plan directs. Ask clients to tell you right away when their insurance changes. If it’s already denied, run eligibility for the date of service. If the client had other coverage on the date of service, confirm the appropriate payer and follow its claim-submission requirements. A coverage-termination denial or your financial policy alone does not establish patient liability. Review the service-date coverage, denial and remark codes, applicable payer-contract terms and patient protections before deciding whether any amount can be billed to the client.
What the code means: “The time limit for filing has expired.” For Original Medicare fee-for-service, a valid claim generally must be received by the appropriate Medicare contractor within 12 months of the date of service; limited exceptions apply. Check the applicable plan and provider agreement for other payers rather than assuming one filing window. Initial filing, correction and appeal deadlines are separate. See CMS Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 1, sections 70–70.7.
Mental health example: A solo psychologist finds that a batch of 90791 intake claims was rejected by the clearinghouse and never reached the payer. By the time anyone notices, the payer’s 90-day filing window has closed.
The fix: Submit claims promptly and review acknowledgment and rejection reports so unsuccessful submissions do not sit unnoticed. Track each payer’s receipt requirements and filing deadline; a transmission record alone does not establish that a valid claim reached the appropriate payer. For a timely-filing denial, check the payer’s review or exception process and retain the documentation it requires. CGS explains that Medicare untimely-filing determinations are not subject to appeal; qualifying filing-limit exceptions are a separate consideration.
What the code means: “These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a ‘medical necessity’ by the payer.” The payer decided the service wasn’t needed based on its clinical criteria.
Mental health example: A client with generalized anxiety disorder (F41.1) has had 24 sessions of 90837. The payer reviews the records and denies further sessions because the notes repeat “client doing well” without describing symptoms, functional impairment or progress toward goals. Payers also target 90837 when the notes don’t justify a 53+ minute session over a 45-minute 90834.
The fix: Make every note connect symptoms, functional impairment, treatment goals and measurable progress, and keep an up-to-date treatment plan. Learn each payer’s criteria for ongoing care. For a disputed medical-necessity determination, follow the denial notice and applicable plan’s clinical-review, reconsideration and appeal sequence; a formal appeal is not always the first step. A corrected claim addresses incorrect claim information, not the clinical disagreement itself. Send the treatment plan, recent notes, standardized scores (like PHQ-9 or GAD-7) and a letter of medical necessity. You can also ask for a peer-to-peer review with the payer’s clinician.
What the code means: “The benefit for this service is included in the payment/allowance for another service/procedure that has already been adjudicated.” The payer treats the service as included in payment for another adjudicated service. Check the remittance details and applicable payer policy to identify the reason; the code alone does not identify a particular NCCI edit.
Mental health example: A clinician bills the interactive complexity add-on 90785 with the crisis psychotherapy code 90839. CMS guidance says not to bill interactive complexity with psychotherapy for crisis. Separately, when psychotherapy add-on 90833 is reported with an E/M service, the psychotherapy time must exclude E/M time, and the documentation must support separately identifiable services.
The fix: Check the code pair, service date and applicable payer policy before adding a modifier. For Medicare NCCI procedure-to-procedure edits, a modifier indicator of 0 does not permit an NCCI-associated modifier to bypass the edit; indicator 1 permits one only when the documented circumstances meet its criteria. Use modifier 59 only when no more specific modifier is appropriate; 59 and XU are not interchangeable fixes for every bundled service. If the bundling adjustment is correct, record the applicable provider adjustment. CMS states that services denied under Medicare NCCI code-pair edits cannot be billed to the Medicare patient. If you dispute the adjustment or need to correct claim data, follow the payer’s correction, reopening or appeal instructions and submit the required supporting records; CO-97 alone does not identify that route.
What the code means: “Claim/service not covered by this payer/contractor. You must send the claim/service to the correct payer/contractor.”
Mental health example: This one is especially common in behavioral health because of “carve-outs.” A client’s medical plan is Blue Cross, but their mental health benefits are managed by a separate behavioral health company. The practice bills Blue Cross and gets CO-109. Medicaid managed care creates the same problem when the claim goes to state fee-for-service Medicaid instead of the client’s managed care plan.
The fix: Read the back of the insurance card for a separate “behavioral health” or “mental health” phone number or payer ID, and confirm it during benefit verification. If the claim went to the wrong payer, submit it to the verified responsible payer and check that payer’s filing requirements and deadline. Keep the CO-109 remittance and submission evidence; do not assume the original submission extends another payer’s deadline. If you believe the receiving payer was responsible, review the remark codes and follow its applicable correction, reopening or appeal process rather than assuming no review is available.
What the code means: “Payment adjusted because the payer deems the information submitted does not support this many/frequency of services.”
Mental health example: A payer reports CARC 151 because the submitted information does not support the number or frequency of services billed. Review the actual remittance and the applicable plan’s coverage and documentation requirements; do not assume that a second 90791 evaluation within 12 months, two 90837 sessions in one week, or a particular number of testing units automatically produces this adjustment. For example, First Coast’s Medicare LCD L33252 permits repeat diagnostic evaluation in specified circumstances, including an extended treatment hiatus, inpatient psychiatric admission, or a significant mental-status change requiring further assessment. That contractor’s policy is not an all-payer frequency limit.
The fix: During verification, ask about visit limits, per-code frequency limits and testing unit caps, and track each client’s used visits. For a returning client, select the code that describes the service actually performed and documented; do not substitute a psychotherapy code solely because a plan limits repeat evaluations. Check the applicable payer’s repeat-evaluation coverage and review process. First Coast’s Medicare coding guidance states that the submitted CPT/HCPCS code must describe the service performed. If extra sessions were clinically needed, appeal with documentation that explains why, such as a crisis, a hospitalization or a new diagnosis.
What the code means: “Precertification/notification/authorization/pre-treatment absent.” Authorizations ranked second among the denial triggers reported in Experian Health’s 2025 survey of healthcare professionals.
Mental health example: A psychologist completes an ADHD evaluation and bills 96130 and 96136 psychological testing codes. The client’s plan requires prior authorization for testing, and none was requested, so every line is denied CO-197. Intensive outpatient programs, TMS and sessions beyond an authorized visit count are frequent triggers too.
The fix: Check authorization rules during benefit verification for every code you plan to bill. Record the authorization number, approved units, dates and rendering provider, and set reminders before approved visits run out. Contact the payer promptly to check whether retrospective authorization or review is available for the member’s plan and service, and confirm its eligibility criteria, required records and deadline. If the claim has been denied, follow the applicable reconsideration or appeal sequence rather than assuming an immediate appeal is the next step. Include evidence of any applicable emergency exception, existing authorization or policy showing authorization was not required.
| Denial reason | CARC | Mental health example | Fix | Corrected claim or appeal? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Missing or incorrect information | CO-16 | Telehealth 90837 missing rendering NPI or POS 10 | Scrub claims before submission | Check claim status and payer instructions: a new claim, correction or other review route may apply |
| Duplicate claim | OA-18 (CO only where state workers’ compensation regulations require it) | 90834 resubmitted while the original was still pending | Check original claim status and payer-specific correction instructions | Reconcile the original claim before deciding on further action |
| Coordination of benefits | CO-22 | Child billed to the wrong parent’s plan | Collect all plans; confirm the applicable coordination rules and payer order | Client updates COB, then rebill |
| Coverage terminated | CO-27 | Client lost job coverage mid-treatment | Re-verify eligibility monthly | Confirm service-date coverage and the correct payer; check contract terms and patient protections before billing the client |
| Timely filing expired | CO-29 | Rejected 90791 claims never reached the payer | Review acknowledgments and rejections promptly | Check the payer’s review or exception route and required evidence |
| Not medically necessary | CO-50 | Notes don’t show impairment after 24 sessions | Tie notes to the treatment plan | Follow the plan’s clinical-review, reconsideration or appeal process |
| Bundled service | CO-97 | 90785 billed with 90839 | Check NCCI edits | Verify edit/modifier rules; adjust or follow payer review route |
| Wrong payer | CO-109 | Behavioral health carve-out billed to medical plan | Verify the behavioral health payer ID | Submit to the verified responsible payer; if the routing decision is disputed, follow the receiving payer’s applicable review process |
| Frequency limit exceeded | CO-151 | Second 90791 within 12 months | Track visit and code limits | Appeal if clinically justified |
| No prior authorization | CO-197 | Psychological testing (96130/96136) without auth | Track authorizations and units | Check retrospective-review eligibility and the applicable reconsideration or appeal route |
CARC means Claim Adjustment Reason Code, shown on the EOB or 835 remittance. X12 group codes categorize the payment adjustment: CO means Contractual Obligation, PR means Patient Responsibility, OA means Other Adjustment, and PI means Payor Initiated Reduction. A PR code alone does not establish that the client may legally be billed. Read the accompanying remark codes and check applicable coverage, payer-contract terms and patient protections before sending a bill. For example, CMS prohibits billing Qualified Medicare Beneficiaries (QMBs) for Medicare Part A or Part B cost sharing, including deductibles, coinsurance and copayments.
Before responding, read the acknowledgment or remittance and identify whether the claim was returned as unprocessable or adjudicated. A reason code alone does not determine the submission format or review route. Follow the payer’s instructions for a new claim, corrected claim, reopening, reconsideration or appeal, as applicable. CMS excludes minor-error corrections from the Medicare appeals process. UnitedHealthcare distinguishes corrections to an adjudicated claim from reconsideration when you disagree with the processing outcome. Use the applicable payer’s form or portal and check the deadline for that specific route.
Consider an appeal when the applicable process and evidence support it. In its analysis of 2024 HealthCare.gov qualified health plan data, KFF reported that consumers internally appealed fewer than 1% of in-network denied claims and insurers upheld 66% of denials on appeal. HealthCare.gov’s consumer internal-appeal guidance says to file within 180 days of receiving the denial notice. Do not apply that consumer deadline automatically to a provider payment dispute; check the applicable plan, agreement, notice and procedural stage. An upheld internal denial may qualify for independent external review, depending on the denial and applicable process. HealthCare.gov lists eligible categories, including medical-judgment denials, experimental or investigational treatment determinations, and certain cancellations of coverage. Check the final denial notice and plan process rather than assuming every provider payment dispute qualifies.
Work through this list before you send any appeal:
When you’re dealing with insurance recoupments rather than denials, the process is different. Get expert help before you respond.
Not sure which denials are costing you the most?
Get a free denial audit. Send us your last 90 days of denials or ERAs, and we’ll show you your top CARC codes, how much is still recoverable, and the fixes that will stop them from coming back.
Denials are much cheaper to prevent than to fix. Use this checklist at the front end:
For more practical fixes, see our mental health billing tips and our guide to common insurance billing challenges for mental health professionals.
If denials keep taking up your time, a specialist can take the work off your plate. Learn how a mental health billing company reduces claim denials, explore our mental health billing services, or see how much mental health billing services cost.
Use this checklist when comparing ePsych Billing with other billing services.
For a sample unresolved claim, ask the billing service to explain the current payer status, the source and date of that status, the last completed action, and the next action. Identify who owns each step: the billing team, practice administrator, treating clinician, or another party. If a record or approval is missing, record what is needed and who will request it. Use approved secure systems for claim-specific information; do not post patient details in a public review or comment.
Ask how the team records the applicable payer deadline, where that deadline was verified, and when the item will next be reviewed. The deadline and the team’s follow-up date are different fields. Agree on an escalation contact for an unanswered request rather than assuming a generic status such as pending explains the delay.
Request a sample report with clearly defined statuses. For example, distinguish awaiting practice information, response submitted, awaiting payer decision, payment posted, and closed without payment. Ask what evidence supports a closed status and how unresolved balances remain visible.
When comparing denial rates, specify the reporting period, whether the measure counts claims or service lines, the denominator, and how repeat denials are counted. Keep dollars billed, dollars paid, and amounts still unresolved separate. A change in the mix of payers or claims can make two percentages difficult to compare.
Put responsibility for pre-transition denials and open appeals in writing. Ask who keeps the history, who can access the payer response, who follows items after service ends, and whether that work has a separate fee. For percentage-based pricing, confirm how collections on older claims enter the agreed fee base.
Use our onboarding and billing-report questions to structure that discussion, and our ePsych Billing pricing explainer to compare fee assumptions.
In Experian Health’s 2025 State of Claims survey of 250 healthcare professionals responsible for financial, billing or claims management decisions, missing or inaccurate claim data ranked first among reported denial triggers, followed by authorizations. Review your own denial data by payer and reason code to identify the leading causes in your practice.
Check the acknowledgment or remittance notice before deciding how to respond. In Medicare Part B, CGS explains that claims returned as unprocessable for incomplete or invalid information have no appeal rights and must be corrected and resubmitted as new claims. That is different from an adjudicated denial. For an adjudicated claim, follow the payer’s applicable correction, reopening or appeal instructions; CMS says minor-error corrections do not go through the Medicare appeals process.
HealthCare.gov says consumers must file an internal appeal within 180 days of receiving the denial notice. That is not a universal deadline for a provider payment dispute. Check the applicable plan, provider agreement and notice for the correct process, deadline and triggering event; keep initial filing, correction and appeal clocks separate. Original Medicare determinations that a claim was not filed timely are not subject to appeal, although limited filing-limit exceptions may apply.
The response depends on the claim’s status and the payer’s instructions. CGS Medicare Part B directs providers to correct claims returned as unprocessable and submit them as new claims, not appeals. UnitedHealthcare instructs providers to wait for adjudication before submitting a corrected claim with frequency code 7 and the original claim number; disagreement with the processing outcome can follow its reconsideration route. CMS excludes minor-error corrections from the Medicare appeals process. Check the applicable process and deadline rather than assuming every returned claim needs a replacement claim or appeal.
ACA-compliant health plans can’t deny coverage for pre-existing conditions. Grandfathered individual plans, short-term health plans and some limited-benefit policies can still exclude them.
Verify benefits and authorizations before treatment, document session time and medical necessity in every note, scrub claims before submission, and track denial trends by payer. Many practices use an insurance billing service to handle this full cycle.
CO means Contractual Obligation; PR means Patient Responsibility. These group codes categorize payment adjustments, but a PR code alone is not permission to bill the client. Check the accompanying remark codes, service-date coverage, applicable payer-contract terms and patient protections. For example, CMS prohibits billing Qualified Medicare Beneficiaries for Medicare Part A or Part B deductibles, coinsurance and copayments. Noridian explains that QMB remittances can still display PR amounts together with QMB-specific remark codes. See Noridian’s QMB remittance guidance.
ePsych Billing is run by a founder with a Master’s in Psychology who understands both the clinical and the billing side of mental health practice. We verify benefits, submit clean claims, and work every denial so you can focus on your clients—read our ePsych Billing reviews and billing process and client support guide.
See what ePsych Billing’s claim denial management service covers.
Start with a free denial audit. We’ll review your recent denials and ERAs, break them down by CARC code and payer, estimate how much revenue you can still recover, and give you a short list of fixes for your front desk and billing workflow. There’s no cost and no obligation.

Alex holds a Master's degree in Psychology and is a mental health billing expert who helps mental health professionals collect more revenue as owner of ePsych Billing.
We use essential technologies to run this site. With your permission, we also use analytics to understand visits and marketing technologies to measure and personalize advertising. You can accept, reject or choose optional categories. Your choice does not prevent you from contacting us.
Essential technologies keep the site and contact-form protection working. Analytics and marketing are optional and start off. You can change your choices at any time using Cookie settings.
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us understand how visitors use our website.
Marketing cookies are used to follow visitors to websites. The intention is to show ads that are relevant and engaging to the individual user.
You can find more information in our Privacy Policy and .